gericat (!empty($user->lang['WROTE'])) ? $user->lang['WROTE'] : ucwords(strtolower(str_replace('_', ' ', 'WROTE'))):
Tell me about hand laying track.
I've been out of the hobby for (can't believe) 35 years or so. As a teen I was building and doing well at shows with Fine Scale kits, so I've always been enthralled with scratch building and craftsmanship. But then, cars, girls, a military career...you know how it goes.
But I recently had my interest revived, if only to sample how the hobby has changed. I'd long wanted to hand lay track, but try as folks might, it just never made sense when I would simply read about it. Nobody I knew (or know) hand lays track, so I couldn't mentor with someone.
Well the hobby has changed! Being an electrical and computer engineer, you can imagine I'm fascinated with DCC. So while reading up, I came across Fast Tracks. I was blown away, to say the least. Now I can scratch-build quality turnouts, and with a little practice (I'm sure), each turnout can be precise and professional.
So, to your comment about talking hand-laid track. For me there is always the craftsmanship aspect. I'd scratch build everything if I could, although I have a soft spot for brass locomotives. But it's very satisfying and enjoyable.
But more than that, once you see hand-laid track, especially next to commercial offerings, there is a noticeable difference in realism. Hand-laid track just looks more realistic to my eye. There is also the issue of conventional track lines. Or, to say it a different way, not all curves are perfect curves. If you look at nearly any prototypical track, rarely are they ever perfectly curved. They tend to follow the lay of the land, especially in hilly and mountainous areas. It's fine to have a perfect curve in a layout, but depending on location and arrangement, I think it can it look artificial at times. Forced. Track follows land, land doesn't follow track. Commercial track, omitting flex track of course, is perfect in every aspect.
There is also tie composition and appearance. I can't say what's used today, but back in the day the ties were plastic ("Delran" I believe?) and a glossy black color. No tie in the world is glossy black! And few are actually a deep black color. Creosote is more a blackish-brown color.
And the turnouts...well, as Tim alludes to in some of his videos (e.g.: frog), commercial turnouts make compromises, and they're immediately noticeable, at least to my eye. And unless things have changed, having the switch motor connected to the turnout is just not realistic. Many are built that way.
This isn't to "slam" commercial track. Far from it. It's just a, well, a lifestyle choice I suppose. There is a time and place for RTR track, but there is a time and place for well crafted, hand-laid track. It just depends on what your individual modeling goals are.
Can't thank Tim and Ron enough for the jigs, though. The entire concept is amazing, and I can't wait to get my first order in start!